I had been scheduled to meet with Dr. Rick Delamarter on Monday April 7th, but I cancelled the appointment this morning in order to concentrate on recovering from my knee surgery which was performed by Dr. Christopher Behr on March 26. Delamarter was highly recommended by Dr. Larry Dodge, and the appointment was scheduled to discuss alternatives including disc replacement. Obviously this is quite important as I would have to take the whole day off to drive up to L.A. and back for this appointment. According to Delamarter's secretary, it is not uncommon for people to come see the doctor from outside the area. So, he must be good, right....?
Dr. Rick Delamarter
L.A. Spine Institute
1301 20th Street, Suite 400
Santa Monica, CA
(310) 828-7757
laspineinstitute.com
Monday, March 31, 2008
Wednesday, March 19, 2008
Sunday, March 16, 2008
brief discussion with Toby
I saw Toby at church and very briefly chatted about my situation. He agreed that I should give the ESI procedure another chance. He also agreed that IDET did not necessarily work to relieve the pain. Apparently the people who did the initial study had great results, patented the procedure, made a bunch of money, and have since retired. It seems that there is a big difference in success rates depending on the viability of the candidate. From everything I've seen, I would not be the best candidate since I don't have much of a disc left.
We briefly touched on fusion and disc replacement. He didn't think that fusion was the best possible procedure since it puts pressure on the adjoining discs. He reemphasized that disc replacement is a very new procedure, and the medical community simply does not know the long turn effects.
We briefly touched on fusion and disc replacement. He didn't think that fusion was the best possible procedure since it puts pressure on the adjoining discs. He reemphasized that disc replacement is a very new procedure, and the medical community simply does not know the long turn effects.
Thursday, March 13, 2008
disc replacement
Obviously I am very nervous about even considering disc replacement since it is major surgery and there does not seem to be any studies on long-term effects. I believe the procedure was only approved in the U.S. within the last year or so, although supposedly it has been done in Europe for a somewhat longer period of time. I need to do some research.
I remember talking with the orthopedic doctors at Kaiser about disc replacement, and they sort of lumped it in with fusion. Bottom line is that almost every doctor has told me that surgery should be a last resort. If I can manage the pain, then it is best to do that and avoid a procedure which may or may not relieve my pain. Once you get surgery, then you've got stuff in your body and you cannot go back to where you were before....
I remember talking with the orthopedic doctors at Kaiser about disc replacement, and they sort of lumped it in with fusion. Bottom line is that almost every doctor has told me that surgery should be a last resort. If I can manage the pain, then it is best to do that and avoid a procedure which may or may not relieve my pain. Once you get surgery, then you've got stuff in your body and you cannot go back to where you were before....
Wednesday, March 12, 2008
Dr. Larry Dodge
After waiting an hour and a half to finally meet with the Doctor, we were able to discuss options. In addition to looking at my MRI results, pushing on my back in spots, and having me bend in various ways, he took an X-ray of my back bending backwards and forwards.
Like so many other doctors with whom I have spoken, he also did not like the idea of fusion for all the usual reasons (I am young and hopefully active again which would put pressure on the adjoining discs). He said that fusion was a procedure for someone who was age 60, not 40 (like me).
He did seem to think that disc replacement is a viable option and that I had given other treatments a chance to work and that I needed to go ahead and get this fixed. He is referring me to a Dr. Rick Delamarter in Santa Monica who is the "best guy in Southern California, if not the entire Country" for disc replacements. He said that Delamarter had had good success treating people and eliminating back pain in patients. I asked how many disc replacements Delamarter had done, and Dodge said over a thousand. Apparently he was part of the FDA study to get the procedure approved here in the U.S. I mentioned I had discussed disc replacement with a couple of Kaiser doctors, and Dodge dismissingly said they were the "Little League." He said there were some guys up in Encinitas who had done quite a few disc replacements who were "Semi-Pro." He said that in comparison, that Delamarter was a full-blown "Pro."
Like so many other doctors with whom I have spoken, he also did not like the idea of fusion for all the usual reasons (I am young and hopefully active again which would put pressure on the adjoining discs). He said that fusion was a procedure for someone who was age 60, not 40 (like me).
He did seem to think that disc replacement is a viable option and that I had given other treatments a chance to work and that I needed to go ahead and get this fixed. He is referring me to a Dr. Rick Delamarter in Santa Monica who is the "best guy in Southern California, if not the entire Country" for disc replacements. He said that Delamarter had had good success treating people and eliminating back pain in patients. I asked how many disc replacements Delamarter had done, and Dodge said over a thousand. Apparently he was part of the FDA study to get the procedure approved here in the U.S. I mentioned I had discussed disc replacement with a couple of Kaiser doctors, and Dodge dismissingly said they were the "Little League." He said there were some guys up in Encinitas who had done quite a few disc replacements who were "Semi-Pro." He said that in comparison, that Delamarter was a full-blown "Pro."
follow-up with Dr. Dobecki
We talked about the results of the ESI (not too good) Dobecki performed on Feb. 20th.
Dobecki was initially a bit confounded that I seemed to be doing worse (in more pain) after this procedure. However, after I told him that I had been more active right afterwards (e.g., surfing on 2/27) then he thought that might have been a reason for my setback. I forgot to tell him that I had been on the verge of a cold the day of the procedure and, as promised by the nurse, the steroids pushed me into a full-blown week-long cold. Oh well.
Dobecki mentioned that I have some arthritis and facet swelling hypertrophy (sp?) which I had never heard before.
As mentioned previously, if the injections do not work then the next option is IDET type treatments where the doctor heats up (cauterize) the disc. However, Dobecki did not think this was a good treatment option. He said that the results were very hit or miss and he did not have much faith in the procedure. So, he could not recommend it.
I asked about alternative treatments such as putting in a balloon to increase the disc height. He said that I didn't need the balloon because my bones were OK(?)
He said there are some standard procedures which could help me. He said I needed a new spacer between my L5 and S1 vertebrae. Basically we are talking about disc replacement. He wanted me to do some research on spineuniverse.com especially on the following procedures:
In the end, he said that since I was able to go surfing, then perhaps the ESI on 2/20 was effective. So, we decided to try another round next week on March 19th.
Dobecki was initially a bit confounded that I seemed to be doing worse (in more pain) after this procedure. However, after I told him that I had been more active right afterwards (e.g., surfing on 2/27) then he thought that might have been a reason for my setback. I forgot to tell him that I had been on the verge of a cold the day of the procedure and, as promised by the nurse, the steroids pushed me into a full-blown week-long cold. Oh well.
Dobecki mentioned that I have some arthritis and facet swelling hypertrophy (sp?) which I had never heard before.
As mentioned previously, if the injections do not work then the next option is IDET type treatments where the doctor heats up (cauterize) the disc. However, Dobecki did not think this was a good treatment option. He said that the results were very hit or miss and he did not have much faith in the procedure. So, he could not recommend it.
I asked about alternative treatments such as putting in a balloon to increase the disc height. He said that I didn't need the balloon because my bones were OK(?)
He said there are some standard procedures which could help me. He said I needed a new spacer between my L5 and S1 vertebrae. Basically we are talking about disc replacement. He wanted me to do some research on spineuniverse.com especially on the following procedures:
- tlif
- xlif
In the end, he said that since I was able to go surfing, then perhaps the ESI on 2/20 was effective. So, we decided to try another round next week on March 19th.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)