Friday, August 22, 2008

Anthem BC appeal denial

next step is to appeal to CalPERS....

Thursday, August 21, 2008

minor incident report form

Here is the minor incident report I filled out yesterday when I aggravated my back at work. Apparently I am now in the Workers Compensation system.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

aggravated back at work

I significantly aggravated my lower back today standing up at my desk and putting my Design Manual (~10 lbs.?) back onto a shelf. A minor activity, yes, but apparently enough to set my back off. Pain level shot up from a 2-3 to a 5-7. I took a vicodin and a flexiril and basically vegetated at my desk until I was coherent enough to drive home. Lovely. I spoke to some of our admin folks and have decided to file a Workers Compensation claim.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Anthem BC appeal receipt

got this in the mail today....


Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Dr. Mark Nelson - 2nd visit

I met with Mark Nelson again over at Oasis. He has got to be one of the nicest doctors I've met. First off, I thanked him for writing a letter on my behalf which said I'd be a good candidate for disc replacement and which could help my insurance appeal. Then I updated him on my current situation and asked him to review my latest (Jun. '08) MRI and discuss options, including fusion (in case my appeal is denied).

We looked at the MRI, and he zeroed in on the L5/S1 disc space saying it looked "painful" noting the wavy vertebral edge and contrast. He said the L4/L5 looked borderline. We discussed my (Dec. '07) discogram and, although he said it isn't the perfect test, all signs point to discogenic pain.

We then had a lengthy discussion of my options starting with managing my pain, avoiding activities which aggravate the back, and basically doing nothing. He said that was probably the best option and -- with an average pain level of only 2 or 3 -- probably what he would choose. He said it was possible, although perhaps unlikely, that the pain would just go away on its own.

We talked about disc replacement and the pros and cons of that procedure. He was very concerned about the anterior (front-side) surgical approach, especially if they had to modify or remove the discs later. Apparently the scar tissue formed by moving everything aside can be very problematic if a surgeon needs to go in a second time. It is very easy to tear something including one of the major blood vessels (e.g., femoral artery) which traverse the area. He also felt like the FDA study did not show that ADR was significantly better than fusion, and of course no one knows the long-term results. He is still very much on the fence about the efficacy of the procedure and doesn't do them himself.

We then got into fusion, and he seemed a bit reluctant to go there, considering my age and other factors. He said that he rarely does them for back pain by itself but more for relief of sciatic (leg nerve) pain. He said the success rate for fusion is around 50%, and many people do not achieve pain relief. In fact, he said that he would consider a successful fusion to be when a patient tells him nine months later that they have 50-60% pain relief. Furthermore, the recovery is brutal and, for at least a few months, the patient is typically in more pain than before the surgery. He mentioned that he has noticed quite a few surgeries at the hospital for removal of fusion hardware after it had been determined to have not helped the person. He thought it was better to leave the (inert) stuff in there rather than undergo a second surgery, but the point is that there are many cases where fusion simply doesn't relieve back pain, and the patient wants the metal out. I asked him about different materials such as the PEEK or composite rods. He felt like a fusion was a fusion, and the rod composition didn't really matter that much.

I then asked him about some newer alternative techniques I've been reading about such as endoscopic (laser) spine surgery (see laserspineinstitute). He was very skeptical about the laser saying most orthopedic surgeons didn't really see the practicality of the instrument. He compared the procedure to IDET where they burn the edge of the herniated disc -- which likely wouldn't do me much good. He said some of these doctors and medical groups have very good marketing departments, but he told me not to be fooled by these newer procedures which were unlikely to be any better than existing techniques ("nothing new under the sun").

He mentioned that the medical system is set up to encourage surgery. The device manufacturers are interested in selling their products (e.g., artificial discs, fusion rods, etc.) while doctors stand to make significantly more money from surgeries versus office visits. He gave an example of my visit today from which he might pocket $50; but if he did a surgery on me, then he might make $5000. So, is it any wonder that doctors recommend surgery? Sad but true. He was very forthright about my options and finally told me that if he was in my shoes, while understanding the psychological effects of enduring constant low-grade pain, he would still probably hold off on surgery. Things could conceivably get better on their own. Even if bone spurs and arthritis were to develop, it was still not out of the realm of possibility to be pain-free. Bottom line is that doctors still don't understand lower back pain very well, unfortunately.

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

Blue Cross needs more info

I called Joanna from Delamarter's office this morning to ask how things were going. She called back and said that Blue Cross had asked for more information to process the appeal, and she sent them everything I had given them (doctors notes from various sources, incl. Kaiser). So, maybe that's a good sign...?

Monday, August 11, 2008

no more alcohol

I've stopped drinking alcohol, pretty much cold-turkey. I thought it would be more difficult to stop that it has been, but so far I haven't really craved it. Thankfully my pain is at a relatively manageable level which relieves some of the temptation to pour a glass....

The reason I stopped is because I learned that the combination of alcohol with ibuprofen is hard on the liver. And I've been taking pretty high dosages of ibuprofen for well over a year....

The thing I'll miss about the booze is that it really did help with the pain and was a good sleep aid too. Oh well....

Friday, August 8, 2008

Jehovah Rapha

Surely he took up our pain
and bore our suffering,
yet we considered him punished by God,
stricken by him, and afflicted.

But he was pierced for our transgressions,
he was crushed for our iniquities;
the punishment that brought us peace was on him,
and by his wounds we are healed.

-Isaiah 53:4-5

-------------------------------------------
My soul, praise the LORD
and do not forget all His benefits.

He forgives all your sin;
He heals all your diseases.

- Psalm 103:2-3

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

feeling somewhat better

Pain level is down to a 2-3 the last couple of days. I've been getting lots of cracking and popping in my lower back which feels good and I hope is not a bad thing. I had coffee with a co-worker yesterday who was pretty emphatic that the combination of ibuprofen and alcohol can be really harmful for the liver. So, I've decided to cut way back on my liquor consumption. Only had half a glass of wine last night, and I'll be continuing to taper off the booze. I did have to take an extra tramadol yesterday evening, and I can easily see myself having to take more of that and possibly vicodin too. Still waiting to hear about my appeal. My mom has said she wants to fly out to be with me for the surgery, but we have not made travel plans due to the insurance uncertainty....

Tuesday, August 5, 2008

neck MRI + medications

e-mail to Dr. Dobecki:

Thanks for you phone call on Friday. I understand that I have some bulging and possible herniation in my neck, however my symptoms have lessened dramatically. I am basically pain-free in the neck area. However, the back is another story! Speaking of which, I was wondering if you could prescribe me some local pain relievers. I was using some patches called Lidoderm (Lidocaine) which seem to take the edge off the pain when I'm having really bad days, and I am about to run out. Also, a friend at work gave me a packet of gel called Cryoderm which seemed to help also. It's a 10% menthol topical pain reliever which I think is prescription-only too. So, if you could help me with those, that would be much appreciated. And if you think we need to talk about my MRI, then definitely let's set up an appointment. But if my neck is feeling OK, then maybe that is not necessary?
Thanks again for all your help.

Monday, August 4, 2008

acute pain

pain level has definitely increased! and it's more acute, focused on the left side of my lower back. i'm having a rough monday morning after a rough weekend. somehow made it into work. pain level = 5-7. in addition to my usual medication, i've already taken a vicodin this morning; and i just took another tramadol. at night, i'm having 1-3 drinks. usually red wine but sometimes some bourbon or kahlua. i'm being careful about not getting too messed up. it definitely helps with the pain and being able to sleep. i would rather not have to ingest any of this junk.

Saturday, August 2, 2008

FDA - ProDisc approval


link to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval page for the ProDisc artificial disc

Friday, August 1, 2008

Delamarter appeal letter

Joanna faxed me Dr. Delamarter's appeal letter to Blue Cross, so the clock is now officially ticking. They have 30 days, but Joanna said they usually respond much quicker. She thought that we would hear something in a week or so.


no more PT

back pain has definitely become more acute (pain level = 5-6). decided to cancel my remaining four physical therapy appointments. what's the point? clearly i need surgery