Showing posts with label surgery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label surgery. Show all posts

Friday, March 27, 2009

SURGERY DATE

lumbar fusion (two-level: L4/L5 & L5/S1)
Scripps Memorial Hospital (La Jolla)
surgeon: Mark Cutler Nelson, MD

Monday, March 16, 2009

new surgery date

I called Summer at Dr. Nelson's office this morning and asked if we could go for March 26th with a fall back date of March 27th. She called me back and said we are on for March 27th. Right now we are scheduled for around noon, but she is going to try to move it up to the morning....

Friday, March 13, 2009

no surgery today

Today was supposed to be my surgery date, but we postponed the procedure because we were not sure that the Work Comp folks would approve in time. Ironically I got a call from Dr. Nelson's office this afternoon, and they said that Dr. Nelson had been on a conference call with a Work Comp review doctor late yesterday afternoon, and that they faxed over the approval today. So we missed it by only half a day, or thereabouts. Way too close to try to schedule Mom's plane travel here though. I will call on Monday with another proposed date....

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

surgery postponed

I've made an executive decision to postpone my surgery. Mom is supposed to fly out tomorrow, but we still don't know if this is going to happen. Dr. Nelson has not heard back from the Work Comp medical review committee (or whatever it's called). Not surprising though as, according to my adjuster Celia, the request was only sent over on Monday.

I can't really blame anyone as I did sort of "change the rules" at the eleventh hour in going for Work Comp coverage. In my own defense, I did not understand the intricacies of health insurance coverage, was unaware of the advantages of using WorkComp, did not think that Dr. Nelson would be in the Work Comp network, and did not realize I would even be eligible for Work Comp. So, considering that we've done a quick changeover to a whole new insurance coverage, things have actually moved forward quickly.

Now we wait to get formal approval and then reschedule....

Monday, March 2, 2009

pre-op with Dr. Nelson

I plan to ask Dr. Nelson about a few things:
  • Need a Doctor's note to my work detailing how much time I will be away (i.e.: two months on disability leave followed by part-time telecommuting)
  • Strongly request that during the procedure he "prop up" my disc space before setting the cage or whatever is going in there, because I feel that most of my pain is coming from the lack of disc (i.e.: vertebrae bone-on-bone)
  • Make sure that fusion will help relieve facet pain. I feel that I may be getting some pain from the facet joints too....

Thursday, February 19, 2009

scheduled fusion surgery

I just scheduled a 2-level fusion with Dr. Mark Nelson for Friday March 13th at 7:15am at Scripps Memorial Hospital in La Jolla. His nurse assistant will call me back tomorrow to confirm. I am definitely nervous, but I feel like this is the right decision. I suppose it is possible that I could postpone, but as of this moment I am ready to go.

footnote 1: I move into my new apartment this weekend, so I will be living somewhere with more peace and quiet for an improved recovery. Slowly moving things over to the new place every day this week has definitely not been the best thing for my aching back. Looking forward to getting settled and relaxing over the next couple of weeks....

footnote 2: I hope to talk to a couple of more people at work who have had fusions next week -- Beth L. (whom I've talked to before; she has had two fusion surgeries -- same location? not sure) and Greg B. (do not know the details of his procedure at all). I am hopeful that talking to them will be a positive and encouraging thing, since I am still very nervous about going through with this....

Thursday, February 5, 2009

talk with Nance about fusion

I had talked some with Steve's stepmother Nance about her back surgery when she was here in December. Got her number from Steve so I could talk to her more at length.

She had a one-level fusion some 3+ years ago in October 2005, and is doing great today. She cannot feel the cage(s) at all, and has no back issues. She said there is some loss of mobility -- she is just a bit restricted, can't bend over quite as much -- but no pain. I asked about her pain before surgery. Hers was 100% in her legs, so bad that she couldn't sleep for 5 months beforehand. Mine is very different, probably 95% localized to my low back. Side note: supposedly fusion works best at relieving leg pain (sciatic) symptoms, which is not really my problem at all. Or perhaps the gabapentin which I've taken from very early on has relieved my leg nerve issues? Realistically, what else can I do anyway?

We talked about her recovery. She was in the hospital for 5 days because she was so addicted to the pain meds (oxycontin). It was rough for her when she needed pain relief and couldn't get it. Up and showering after 2-3 days. But she spent the first week pretty much in bed. She could walk around more after that week. She could get back on the computer after 10 days. She was driving short distances after 4-6 weeks. She wore a back brace for 6 weeks but did not do PT. She said expect to be off work at least a month, and it would be best to start back at half-days or every other day.

She knew immediately after the surgery that it had worked. Interesting she felt like she was leaning back afterwards since she had been hunched forward for so long and didn't even know it. She had lost 3/4" of height and actually got it back, post surgery.

She was very optimistic and encouraging. She thought I would do better than the average patient since I was healthy and in decent shape. I'm really glad that we talked as it helps me to deal with the fear of surgery.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

no ADR surgery next week

I am definitely not having surgery next week. I've decided to wait and see about disc replacement which I really do think is a better procedure. I finally heard from the State, and they are reviewing the Blue Cross denial. So, we are in limbo again. I guess if/when this happens, it will be in early 2009. If the disc replacement is denied again, then I suppose I would roll the dice on a fusion.

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

the surgery dilemna

I am having a very, very difficult time deciding whether or not to "go under the knife." There are too many variables to process, and the results are too uncertain to be sure.

My pain level has been really up and down lately which makes the decision all the more challenging. When I have days like last Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday, then I'm ready to get surgery as soon as possible. Then I have days like today and yesterday when the pain is really much milder and under control, and I think maybe I can live with it. This week has really been much better than the last, and as a result, I haven't taken Vicodin in a few days. I am back on Ibuprofen though which I had stopped taking last Tuesday Oct. 14th in anticipation of my facet block injection originally scheduled for Fri. Oct. 17th (postponed due to my chest cold/sinus infection which came on Thursday morning).

I'm trying to think about what might have brought on that episode of intense pain last week. I didn't really do anything different that I can recall. I did some pushups a couple days in a row, and perhaps that was too much strain on the back? I watched the OU/Texas game on Oct. 11, and I was very much into it. I remember jumping off my chair a few times to pump my fist, and towards the end of the game I could barely sit down due to the high tension and excitement. So perhaps that somehow flared my back up. The only other thing I can think of is hosting my buddy Roger who came in from Berkeley for the weekend and crashed on my couch Friday and Sunday nights. Maybe just the stress of having an out-of-town visitor, cleaning my place, barbequeing, etc. somehow caused my back to be aggravated. Perhaps a combination of all these factors contributed to what happened. Monday night Oct. 13 was definitely the peak of my pain crescendo. I woke up several times that night, and twice my nerve pain down my right leg was so bad that I got out of bed, put on some sweats, and walked up and down my street under the clear, starry night sky.

The nerve pain down my leg is gone now, but that was definitely the worst. The localized back pain is a bit more comprehensible and seems fairly responsive to stretching. Last week I found that I could not find any kind of position or stretch which would alleviate the leg pain which seemed to flare up sporadically in my right buttcheek, right calf muscle, and right foot. The only thing which helped was more medication. And so the early part of last week is a blur. I didn't work at all. Lots of cable TV and Playstation. Not really the way I want to live. And the medication makes the decision process even more murky.

So, what to do...?

Monday, October 20, 2008

ADR vs. fusion

I've been reading alot of studies comparing disc replacement to fusion. In a nutshell, ADR seems better in the very short term (<6 months) but things supposedly even out after that. At two years, there appears to be little difference in patient pain level and satisfaction. The presumed primary benefit of ADR is that degeneration of adjoining levels would be prevented due to the preservation of mobility, however that hypothesis is as yet unproven since ADR has not been around long enough. There is evidence to show that fusion does lead to adjacent segment degeneration (ASD) after a decade or so. At which point, I guess you just go in for another fusion...? And of course no one really knows the long-term prognosis of ADR.

The Ontario study is the best one I've read so far. Some selected excerpts:

Disadvantages of surgical fusion include loss of movement in the spine, which is thought to promote ASD. Adjacent segment degeneration is the degeneration of the vertebrae above or below the fusion site. It is thought that increased mobility of the adjacent vertebrae, as well as more pressure on the adjacent intervertebral discs as a result of motion transfer from the fused vertebrae may play a key role in the development of ASD. However, it is unclear if ASD is solely related to the spinal fusion process or to the natural degeneration of the vertebrae. The development of ASD is concerning because it can increase the need for additional surgery if it causes symptoms like pain and disability.

The surgical management of chronic low back pain due to DDD is still controversial, with inconsistent evidence to support its effectiveness. In a 2005 systematic review on surgical interventions for lumbar DDD, researchers were unable to determine the superiority of any one fusion technique or combination of techniques when compared with other types of surgical and nonsurgical interventions.

Unlike spinal fusion, ADR preserves movement of the spine, and this is thought to reduce or prevent the development of ASD. The surgical procedure for disc replacement involves an anterior approach for exposure of the spine, which predisposes the patient to vascular injury of the great vessels more so than does the posterior approach of spinal fusion. However, an anterior approach to fusion surgery is also an accepted method. Often a vascular surgeon is needed to carry out the anterior approach, while the actual disc replacement is completed by either an orthopedic surgeon or a neurosurgeon. Revision surgery for ADR is a complicated process because of the scarring around the great vessels from the initial surgery. It has been suggested that the artificial disc is unlikely to have the exact characteristics of the native vertebrae, and because of this different models can be expected to yield different long-term results. The long-term durability of artificial intervertebral discs is unknown.

Sunday, October 5, 2008

why back surgery?

The following is an e-mail to a relative explaining why I am getting back surgery now. I also forwarded to Cherri at Dr. Delamarter's office to see if I had any misconceptions regarding the recovery process. Hopefully she will write back....

Thanks for your concern. I have been very concerned also, but I have come to the decision that I have to get this done. The pain is not getting better. If anything, it's getting worse. In the last month or so, I've started to get numbness, tingling, and pain down my right leg all the way to my foot which is something I had not experienced before. And I haven't done anything which would make things worse. My physical activity is limited to some stretching and basic yoga along with walking. That's all I do. I'm tired of putting my life on hold waiting around hoping this will get better.

The whole insurance thing is a mess. The procedure I would like to have done (artificial disc replacement or ADR) is fairly new (approved by FDA in 2005) so Blue Cross is apparently not yet comfortable with it. They denied my surgery saying it is "experimental" or "investigative." From my research and from talking with a number of orthopedic spine surgeons, I am of the opinion that ADR is the best option for me at this time. I am inclined to move forward with or without the insurance. I am still hoping that (1) somehow my back will get better so that I do not have to get surgery and (2) if I do get surgery, that my insurance will cover it.

So that's where I am. As far as logistics go, mom will be coming out to San Diego the week beforehand and has plans to stay as long as need be. I have to go up to LA the week before to give blood and get checked out. I'll be in the hospital for three days. Recovery time is variable from 2-8 weeks, although I may not feel 100% recovered for six months or even a year. While not brain surgery or heart surgery, spine surgery is still major and quite invasive. They come in through the front. And I'm getting hardware installed into my vertebrae. I think a lot of the recuperation is just recovering from the operation itself. Supposedly the back pain I'm experiencing now will be gone although I may feel some residual nerve pain (hopefully not!) I'll be doing plenty of physical therapy (core strengthening) throughout my recovery.

I really don't see that I have much of a choice right now. I am able to live, but I'm in constant pain. I've had to increase my medication dosage including narcotics (vicodin), and my quality of life is not very good. I've always been very active, and right now I don't do much of anything. I'm getting fat. I occasionally battle depression. Bottom line -- it's time to get this fixed. Thanks for your love and your prayers.

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Blue Cross (Anthem) appeal process

I decided to be proactive about my appeal instead of waiting around for the denial letter, so I called Anthem Blue Cross to inquire. They said that Joanna from Dr. Delamarter's office called on 7/14 for the preauthorization (BC preauth. 1-800-451-6780). BC called back on 7/18 with a denial on the grounds of the procedure being "experimental / investigative." I should receive a denial letter within 3-5 business days. This letter is also sent to Delamarter and the hospital (St. John's, Santa Monica). To expedite the process, I then contacted the BC Appeals Dept. (1-800-365-0609). They said I needed to either file my appeal online, via telephone, or fax to Anthem Blue Cross Grievance and Appeals Dept. at FAX: (818) 234-3824. I need to include my member ID number as well as any supporting information (e.g., doctor's letters) to support my claim.

from Blue Cross Grievance:



How to file a Grievance
Anthem Blue Cross shall ensure that all enrollees have access to and can fully participate in the grievance system by providing assistance for those with limited English proficiency or with visual or other communicative impairment. Such assistance shall include, but not be limited to, translations of grievance procedures, forms and plan responses to grievances, as well as access to interpreters, telephone relay systems and other devices that aid disabled individuals to communicate.
Anthem Blue Cross has a formal process for reviewing member complaints or grievances. This process provides a uniform and equitable treatment of your complaint or grievance and a prompt response.
Standard Grievance Review
Steps in the process
1. File your grievance or complaint with Anthem Blue Cross. You may also authorize someone to represent you. Authorization must be in writing. Call customer service for the authorization form. Your customer service number is on the back of your membership card.

You can file your grievance by:
a. Calling customer service. Your customer service number is on the back your
membership card.
b. Mailing a letter or a completed grievance form which you can get on to website
or by calling customer service or
c. Submitting a grievance form online.
2. We will send you an acknowledgement letter within five (5) calendar days of receipt.
3. We will review your grievance. The process varies by the nature of the grievance. Medical grievances are reviewed by staff medical personnel and some are referred to physician medical specialists. Some types of medical grievances are reviewed twice by two different doctors to ensure that the right decision has been made about your medical coverage. Non-medical grievances are reviewed by grievance specialists. We will provide a written response to you within 30 calendar days after we receive your grievance.
4. If you are dissatisfied with our answer, you may be able to pursue one or more of the following appeal processes, depending on your situation and the appeal information contained in your Evidence of Coverage. If you need assistance please contact customer service at the number on the back of your membership card.
a. File a complaint with the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC)
provided that your Anthem Blue Cross health coverage is governed by
them. Click here for a link to the DMHC web site. Your grievance
acknowledgement letter and response letter from Anthem Blue Cross will include
information on how to contact the Department of Managed Health Care.

If your health coverage is not governed by the DMHC, it may be governed by the
Department of Insurance. Please contact customer service if you are not sure
which entity governs your health coverage. Your customer service number is on
the back of your membership card.
b. Submit a request for binding arbitration. Not all Anthem Blue Cross members
may request binding arbitration. The right to request binding arbitration is
explained in your Evidence of Coverage.
c. Request Independent Medical Review. Independent Medical Review is
available for decisions to deny payment on the basis that the services are not
medically necessary or that they are considered investigational or experimental. If
you are eligible for Independent Medical Review, information will be provided in
our letters to you.
d. Have your case reviewed in an administrative hearing if you are a Medicare
beneficiary or a MediCal enrollee. Those rights are identified in your Evidence of
Coverage.
e. Seek legal remedies in a court of law.
Expedited Review
An expedited review is available when a medical decision has been made to deny a payment and there is "an imminent and serious threat to the health of the enrollee, including but not limited to, serious pain, potential loss of life, limb or major bodily function."
Steps in the process
1. File your grievance or complaint with Anthem Blue Cross using one of the methods listed in the standard grievance process. You may also authorize someone to represent you. Authorization must be in writing. Contact customer service for the authorization form. Your customer service number is on the back of your membership card. Calling customer service is the recommended method of requesting an expedited review.
2. A physician will review your request and make a determination within 72 hours. If your request does not qualify for an expedited review, your grievance will be reviewed in the standard 30-day grievance process. You will be notified by mail if you do not qualify for expedited review.
3. If you qualify for Independent Medical Review, you may appeal directly to the Department of Managed Health Care immediately.

Forms :

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

ADR surgery scheduled

I finally spoke to Joanna the surgery scheduler for Dr. Delamarter, and we have pencilled in Tuesday, September 2 for my two-level disc replacement. She reminded me a few times that Blue Cross (BC) would likely deny the procedure, but I told her I wanted to get the ball rolling. She twice asked me if I had sufficient funds to pay out of pocket, and I told her I did not. [I want them to give maximum effort towards getting Blue Cross to approve.] She informed me that BC would respond within a week, likely with a denial. Then I could appeal the decision in writing. After that, BC has up to 30 days to process the appeal and render a final decision. So, the process has begun. I feel at peace moving forward as I've tried everything else, and my back is not getting better. If anything, it seems to be getting worse, with more pain concentrated on the left side of my low back. It's time to do something. The other factor is the insurance issue. Supposedly Kaiser will approve an ADR. But I only have that brief once-per-year window of opportunity to change insurance in October, to be effective January 1. So, I need to know before then whether or not Blue Cross is going to approve the procedure. And if not, then I'll have another big decision to make: $50,000 for the best (Delamarter) or back to Kaiser for free.

Thursday, May 8, 2008

injections are band-aids

from an e-mail to a friend:

i feel sure you're aware that most (if not all) of these injections are just band-aids. but i'll take any diminishment of the pain, no matter the source! right now my physical therapy people have me on a detox, gluten-free diet which is supposed to reduce inflammation and pain. i'm on my second day and haven't really seen much improvement so far. but i'll give it another couple of days before i give up.

i've yet to schedule with the disc replacement guy
(laspineinstitute.com) because it means i have to take a day off to drive up there and back. and i'm pretty sure that he'll take one look at my MRI and recommend that i get the procedure. i guess i'm still too scared of back surgery. my pain is bad, but it's not yet bad enough for me to go there....

Thursday, March 13, 2008

disc replacement

Obviously I am very nervous about even considering disc replacement since it is major surgery and there does not seem to be any studies on long-term effects. I believe the procedure was only approved in the U.S. within the last year or so, although supposedly it has been done in Europe for a somewhat longer period of time. I need to do some research.

I remember talking with the orthopedic doctors at Kaiser about disc replacement, and they sort of lumped it in with fusion. Bottom line is that almost every doctor has told me that surgery should be a last resort. If I can manage the pain, then it is best to do that and avoid a procedure which may or may not relieve my pain. Once you get surgery, then you've got stuff in your body and you cannot go back to where you were before....