- Should I get another diagnostic facet injection, especially on the left side? yes, scheduled for Wed. June 11 As of May 23, my left side (facet area) has been hurting pretty bad (pain level 4-6) for more than 24 hours straight. Also, Dr. Delamarter mentioned that I had significant arthritis in my left facet joint which was clearly visible on the July 2007 MRI and could be getting worse.
- Should I get another MRI to see where things are? yes, need approval from insurance My last MRI was the previously mentioned July 2007.
Thursday, May 29, 2008
Dr. Dobecki
two points of discussion:
Labels:
Dr. Dobecki,
MRI,
options,
pain management,
strategy
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Dr. Rick Delamarter
I am taking a day off work to drive up to L.A. for this appointment to discuss lower back pain, disc replacement, etc. (Spine Institute 1304 20th Street #400 Santa Monica, CA 90404)
First I met with Delamarter's nurse assistant Cheri Phillips who did all the usual tests (e.g., walk on heels and tiptoes; lean forward, back, and side-to-side; check reflexes, etc.) We then discussed my symptoms and history for awhile, then she left and returned shortly with the doctor.
Delamarter was very knowledgeable, professional, competent, and confident -- all good things I would want in the surgeon who might end up performing back surgery on me. He pretty much cut to the chase and after going over my imagery with me (and quickly realizing that I was more educated than most patients) he proclaimed that he wanted to do a 2-level disc replacement. The fact that he wanted to perform a disc replacement was no surprise, but doing a 2-level was. It does make sense though as my L5/S1 is pretty much gone, and the L4/L5 is starting to go. And, as he said, why replace one and then have to go in and do the second one shortly thereafter? Why not do them both at one time? If the L4/L5 is going to continue to deteriorate (something which I had not really allowed myself to consider) then it's probably the right call. He mentioned in passing that he had just been at a conference in Miami where he presented a paper on the results of 2-level disc replacement compared to 2-level fusion, and his conclusions were that the 2-level replacement was clearly superior, even significantly better than the 1-level vs. 1-level comparison.
Pointing at a plan view of my vertebra, he said that the one major concern was the status of my left facet joint which was showing noticeable arthritis and could worsen. Apparently if it gets bad enough, then that could rule out the disc replacement procedure and leave fusion as my only option. However, he said that an artificial disc could potentially arrest the worsening arthritis.
After Delamarter's spiel began the disc replacement Q&A process for which I had thankfully prepared by earlier writing down several questions. First off was the short-term recovery. He said the patient spends 2-3 days in the hospital although can walk almost immediately. Patient is off of work from 1-2 weeks, although some people need 6-8 weeks to recover sufficiently (knowing doctors and my prior knee surgery experience, I imagine the latter to be more accurate). He said that patients are able to resume full activity (including basketball!) after a few months of rest and physical therapy (core strengthening).
Next, I asked about the long-term prognosis. As I well knew they've only been doing the procedure for 5-6 years here in the US of which he was part of the initial study and has thus been doing them as long as anybody here in this country. According to Delamarter, they've been doing them for approx. 18 years in Europe but he says their data collection is not as reliable. He has had disc replacement patients with 6 years and counting who are experiencing no problems. I asked if the disc replacement was good for life (saying I planned to live another 40-50 years, ha!) and he said that the disc design looks good to last that long, but who really knows? I asked if there had been any problems with the artificial disc? in the body and he went down my list and said "no" to each concern: failure, breakage, subsidence, expulsion / rejection, deterioration.
I was curious about how experienced? he was doing disc replacement. He flatly stated that he had done more disc replacements than anyone else in the US. In all, he has done almost 1,000 procedures including around 700 on the lower back. He claimed a success rate of 90% saying that only 1 in 10 patients had continuing significant symptoms (i.e.: pain) after the disc replacement. (the nurse had previously mentioned a success rate of 95%)
Next I asked him to discuss risks of the procedure. I had heard from other doctors that coming in from the front could present problems due to the presence of large (femoral) blood vessels. He said the risk was less than 1% and that he had an excellent team of doctors to assist in the operation. I asked him about the risk of infection, and as he knocked on the table said that he had never had a problem and the risk was less than 1%.
I wanted to hear about the risks of waiting or not getting the procedure. He said that my arthritis and/or bone spurs could worsen and probably would although the time frame was unknown. Things could get worse in anywhere from 6 months to 10 years but eventually disc replacement might become a non-option whereupon a fusion would be the only possibility. I asked about spondylolisthesis which I had read in a paper as being something that could preclude disc replacement. He said that referred to lateral slipping of the vertebrae and that I did not show significant signs of this problem (certainly less than Stage 1).
First I met with Delamarter's nurse assistant Cheri Phillips who did all the usual tests (e.g., walk on heels and tiptoes; lean forward, back, and side-to-side; check reflexes, etc.) We then discussed my symptoms and history for awhile, then she left and returned shortly with the doctor.
Delamarter was very knowledgeable, professional, competent, and confident -- all good things I would want in the surgeon who might end up performing back surgery on me. He pretty much cut to the chase and after going over my imagery with me (and quickly realizing that I was more educated than most patients) he proclaimed that he wanted to do a 2-level disc replacement. The fact that he wanted to perform a disc replacement was no surprise, but doing a 2-level was. It does make sense though as my L5/S1 is pretty much gone, and the L4/L5 is starting to go. And, as he said, why replace one and then have to go in and do the second one shortly thereafter? Why not do them both at one time? If the L4/L5 is going to continue to deteriorate (something which I had not really allowed myself to consider) then it's probably the right call. He mentioned in passing that he had just been at a conference in Miami where he presented a paper on the results of 2-level disc replacement compared to 2-level fusion, and his conclusions were that the 2-level replacement was clearly superior, even significantly better than the 1-level vs. 1-level comparison.
Pointing at a plan view of my vertebra, he said that the one major concern was the status of my left facet joint which was showing noticeable arthritis and could worsen. Apparently if it gets bad enough, then that could rule out the disc replacement procedure and leave fusion as my only option. However, he said that an artificial disc could potentially arrest the worsening arthritis.
After Delamarter's spiel began the disc replacement Q&A process for which I had thankfully prepared by earlier writing down several questions. First off was the short-term recovery. He said the patient spends 2-3 days in the hospital although can walk almost immediately. Patient is off of work from 1-2 weeks, although some people need 6-8 weeks to recover sufficiently (knowing doctors and my prior knee surgery experience, I imagine the latter to be more accurate). He said that patients are able to resume full activity (including basketball!) after a few months of rest and physical therapy (core strengthening).
Next, I asked about the long-term prognosis. As I well knew they've only been doing the procedure for 5-6 years here in the US of which he was part of the initial study and has thus been doing them as long as anybody here in this country. According to Delamarter, they've been doing them for approx. 18 years in Europe but he says their data collection is not as reliable. He has had disc replacement patients with 6 years and counting who are experiencing no problems. I asked if the disc replacement was good for life (saying I planned to live another 40-50 years, ha!) and he said that the disc design looks good to last that long, but who really knows? I asked if there had been any problems with the artificial disc? in the body and he went down my list and said "no" to each concern: failure, breakage, subsidence, expulsion / rejection, deterioration.
I was curious about how experienced? he was doing disc replacement. He flatly stated that he had done more disc replacements than anyone else in the US. In all, he has done almost 1,000 procedures including around 700 on the lower back. He claimed a success rate of 90% saying that only 1 in 10 patients had continuing significant symptoms (i.e.: pain) after the disc replacement. (the nurse had previously mentioned a success rate of 95%)
Next I asked him to discuss risks of the procedure. I had heard from other doctors that coming in from the front could present problems due to the presence of large (femoral) blood vessels. He said the risk was less than 1% and that he had an excellent team of doctors to assist in the operation. I asked him about the risk of infection, and as he knocked on the table said that he had never had a problem and the risk was less than 1%.
I wanted to hear about the risks of waiting or not getting the procedure. He said that my arthritis and/or bone spurs could worsen and probably would although the time frame was unknown. Things could get worse in anywhere from 6 months to 10 years but eventually disc replacement might become a non-option whereupon a fusion would be the only possibility. I asked about spondylolisthesis which I had read in a paper as being something that could preclude disc replacement. He said that referred to lateral slipping of the vertebrae and that I did not show significant signs of this problem (certainly less than Stage 1).
Friday, May 16, 2008
Dr. Mark Nelson
Oasis is an impressive office with numerous signed photos of various pro athletes including LT, Junior Seau, and Michael Jordan. I had a fairly thorough meeting with Doctor Nelson. He looked at my MRI results, and we talked about fusion and disc replacement. He agreed that fusion was not a good option since I'm young and it would put additional stress on the adjoining vertebrae. He said that he was "on the fence" about disc replacement and did not perform them himself because he was not yet sufficiently comfortable with the procedure. He went on to say that they've been done for around 10 years in Europe but for only 6-7 years here in the States; so there is no clinical information regarding long-term prospects. However, he said that out of all the people he has met, I was one of the best -- if not the best -- candidate he had ever seen for the procedure since I am young and in decent physical condition (e.g., not overweight).
He recommended that I see Dr. Delamarter on Wednesday as planned, although he cautioned me that Delamarter would probably recommend that I get the disc replacement since he seems to be quite an advocate of the procedure. We had a good laugh at Delamarter's website which is "very L.A." Dr. Nelson also recommended that I see a Dr. Peppers in Encinitas who also does disc replacements and is supposedly a bit more level-headed in his evaluations. He went on to tell me about some of the risks of the procedure. They go in through the front which can be a bit problematic due to the presence of some large blood (femoral) vessels. The other major (although unlikely) risk is infection. Either situation would be fairly catastrophic with the infection requiring a subsequent fusion operation. However if one of the large blood vessels were compromised in moving them out of the way to access the spine, a patient could bleed to death in a matter of minutes. Scary stuff!
--------------------------
appointment with Dr. Mark Nelson, MD at:
Oasis Spine Center
5471 Kearny Villa Rd, Suite 200
San Diego 92123-1143
(858) 571-0606
FAX: 571-1933
from the website:
Dr. Mark Nelson is a Board Certified Orthopaedic Surgeon and Spine Specialist offering surgical and non-surgical spine treatments....
Dr. Nelson moved to San Diego, CA where he joined Oasis Sports Medical Group, the area’s premier Sports Orthopaedic Group with a long history of treating professional, collegiate, and recreational athletes. Here at Oasis Spine Center, Dr. Nelson has merged the lessons of sports medicine with the best in modern spinal treatment to create the Oasis Spine Center – committed to getting you back in your game!
He recommended that I see Dr. Delamarter on Wednesday as planned, although he cautioned me that Delamarter would probably recommend that I get the disc replacement since he seems to be quite an advocate of the procedure. We had a good laugh at Delamarter's website which is "very L.A." Dr. Nelson also recommended that I see a Dr. Peppers in Encinitas who also does disc replacements and is supposedly a bit more level-headed in his evaluations. He went on to tell me about some of the risks of the procedure. They go in through the front which can be a bit problematic due to the presence of some large blood (femoral) vessels. The other major (although unlikely) risk is infection. Either situation would be fairly catastrophic with the infection requiring a subsequent fusion operation. However if one of the large blood vessels were compromised in moving them out of the way to access the spine, a patient could bleed to death in a matter of minutes. Scary stuff!
--------------------------
appointment with Dr. Mark Nelson, MD at:
Oasis Spine Center
5471 Kearny Villa Rd, Suite 200
San Diego 92123-1143
(858) 571-0606
FAX: 571-1933
Dr. Mark Nelson is a Board Certified Orthopaedic Surgeon and Spine Specialist offering surgical and non-surgical spine treatments....
Dr. Nelson moved to San Diego, CA where he joined Oasis Sports Medical Group, the area’s premier Sports Orthopaedic Group with a long history of treating professional, collegiate, and recreational athletes. Here at Oasis Spine Center, Dr. Nelson has merged the lessons of sports medicine with the best in modern spinal treatment to create the Oasis Spine Center – committed to getting you back in your game!
Wednesday, May 14, 2008
there is no day 3
As of approximately 8:39pm last night, I am off the #$&*%! diet.
MHPT owner Ralph had given me his cell phone number to call if I didn't feel well, had questions, etc. I called him yesterday when I got home from work and was feeling continued symptoms of nausea, headache, and dizziness -- all combined with extreme hunger. Downed a shake and some broccoli and still felt like absolute crap. I usually take my medication every twelve hours around 7:30 but did not want to take anything while feeling that way. Waited and waited for a return phone call and finally realized that life is too short to suffer in that way for questionable benefits. I stumbled down to the Co-op, grabbed a salad and some soy milk to put in a real smoothie (with fruit) and returned home to eat a somewhat more substantive dinner with my meds. And sure enough, I felt better almost immediately.
The amazing thing is that my back feels improved today. I took a brief walk this morning and sat in a GIS class all day, and my back still feels better than it did on that stupid diet. And my disposition is light-years improved. So, the question now is whether I keep these twice per week appointments at MHPT or if I cancel them all and bail on that program. I'm leaning towards the latter. I really do like the staff there personally, but the fact that Ralph has still yet to return my call does not speak well to their empathy or professionalism.
In the meantime, I have made another appointment with Dr. Rick Delamarter of the L.A. Spine Institute one week from today. I will have to take the day off and make the hell-drive, but I need to hear what he has to say. Virginia here at work recommended Oasis Sports Medicine saying they've worked on the Chargers, Padres, etc. So, I made an appointment with their spine guy Dr. Mark Nelson for this Friday.
It's time to get something done, and I feel OK about it. I've been reading more about disc replacement, and it can supposdly be done on an outpatient basis with an 8-10 day recovery time. That is absolutely stunning compared to a fusion procedure. Of course the 800 lb. gorilla in the room is the long-term prospects which nobody really knows. They just haven't been done long enough.
MHPT owner Ralph had given me his cell phone number to call if I didn't feel well, had questions, etc. I called him yesterday when I got home from work and was feeling continued symptoms of nausea, headache, and dizziness -- all combined with extreme hunger. Downed a shake and some broccoli and still felt like absolute crap. I usually take my medication every twelve hours around 7:30 but did not want to take anything while feeling that way. Waited and waited for a return phone call and finally realized that life is too short to suffer in that way for questionable benefits. I stumbled down to the Co-op, grabbed a salad and some soy milk to put in a real smoothie (with fruit) and returned home to eat a somewhat more substantive dinner with my meds. And sure enough, I felt better almost immediately.
The amazing thing is that my back feels improved today. I took a brief walk this morning and sat in a GIS class all day, and my back still feels better than it did on that stupid diet. And my disposition is light-years improved. So, the question now is whether I keep these twice per week appointments at MHPT or if I cancel them all and bail on that program. I'm leaning towards the latter. I really do like the staff there personally, but the fact that Ralph has still yet to return my call does not speak well to their empathy or professionalism.
In the meantime, I have made another appointment with Dr. Rick Delamarter of the L.A. Spine Institute one week from today. I will have to take the day off and make the hell-drive, but I need to hear what he has to say. Virginia here at work recommended Oasis Sports Medicine saying they've worked on the Chargers, Padres, etc. So, I made an appointment with their spine guy Dr. Mark Nelson for this Friday.
It's time to get something done, and I feel OK about it. I've been reading more about disc replacement, and it can supposdly be done on an outpatient basis with an 8-10 day recovery time. That is absolutely stunning compared to a fusion procedure. Of course the 800 lb. gorilla in the room is the long-term prospects which nobody really knows. They just haven't been done long enough.
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
day 2
- this diet sucks. i'm pretty much constantly hungry. the shake tastes awful. and raw green vegetables are not usually my food of choice. i'm eating green beans today. oh joy!
- my pain level was pretty awful last night, around a 7. between that and my gnawing stomach, i decided to just go to bed early. i suppose that's better than my usual alcohol and vicodin and/or flexiril routine. i suppose....
- the back pain is noticeably diminished today. i'd say a 2. go figure
Monday, May 12, 2008
detox diet
Day 1 of this detox diet which I somehow let Ralph, Kanoe and the rest of the folks at Mission Hills PT talk me into. They seem to think it will really help my back pain, something about normal food causing inflammation which leads to pain. Of course I am taking a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) now (ibuprofen), so if I could achieve the same results through my diet, then I reckon that would be a good thing.
The thing is I will pretty much try anything right now if there's even a slim chance that it will make me better (i.e.: relieve my pain and keep me from going under the surgeon's knife). But I have just about exhausted all the possibilities. In fact, this is basically my last straw. Isn't it remarkable that sometimes when all hope is gone, that's when a miracle happens. Well, I am praying that will be the case with my back getting healed.
I just keep thinking back to those 1-1/2 days of pain-free life I had after Kanoe did some pressure point manipulation of my back, and that's what I'm hanging my hat on. She says it didn't "take" because I've got all this other stuff going on. So, we're going to try to get most of the toxins out of my system and then go on a new (gluten-free) diet, and they think I will really notice a difference.
I must say that this diet is not easy. I made an aborted attempt last week which ended when they told me I was cheating by adding fruit and honey to the smoothie and adding butter, lemon, and seasoning to my broccoli. So, this time I'm doing it correctly even if it's brutal. The smoothie is a bit harsh, tasting something like a watered down pina colada mixed with a bunch of chalk. The powder doesn't want to dissolve, so you get to really enjoy the lovely texture. For solid food, I get to eat one green vegetable a day, all day. I can add olive oil and sea salt. That's it! Sounds simple, eh?
Right now my pain level is not too bad. It was probably a 2.5 before I went to PT, and it's a 3.5 now after lying on Kanoe's hand for an hour (she's trying to straighten my pelvis?). My energy level is low and I'm pretty unenthused about life. Basically business as usual for the last year and a half of my existence. I intend to use this blog to document any changes in my physical / mental / emotional condition (hopefully improvements!)
The thing is I will pretty much try anything right now if there's even a slim chance that it will make me better (i.e.: relieve my pain and keep me from going under the surgeon's knife). But I have just about exhausted all the possibilities. In fact, this is basically my last straw. Isn't it remarkable that sometimes when all hope is gone, that's when a miracle happens. Well, I am praying that will be the case with my back getting healed.
I just keep thinking back to those 1-1/2 days of pain-free life I had after Kanoe did some pressure point manipulation of my back, and that's what I'm hanging my hat on. She says it didn't "take" because I've got all this other stuff going on. So, we're going to try to get most of the toxins out of my system and then go on a new (gluten-free) diet, and they think I will really notice a difference.
I must say that this diet is not easy. I made an aborted attempt last week which ended when they told me I was cheating by adding fruit and honey to the smoothie and adding butter, lemon, and seasoning to my broccoli. So, this time I'm doing it correctly even if it's brutal. The smoothie is a bit harsh, tasting something like a watered down pina colada mixed with a bunch of chalk. The powder doesn't want to dissolve, so you get to really enjoy the lovely texture. For solid food, I get to eat one green vegetable a day, all day. I can add olive oil and sea salt. That's it! Sounds simple, eh?
Right now my pain level is not too bad. It was probably a 2.5 before I went to PT, and it's a 3.5 now after lying on Kanoe's hand for an hour (she's trying to straighten my pelvis?). My energy level is low and I'm pretty unenthused about life. Basically business as usual for the last year and a half of my existence. I intend to use this blog to document any changes in my physical / mental / emotional condition (hopefully improvements!)
Thursday, May 8, 2008
injections are band-aids
from an e-mail to a friend:
i feel sure you're aware that most (if not all) of these injections are just band-aids. but i'll take any diminishment of the pain, no matter the source! right now my physical therapy people have me on a detox, gluten-free diet which is supposed to reduce inflammation and pain. i'm on my second day and haven't really seen much improvement so far. but i'll give it another couple of days before i give up.
i've yet to schedule with the disc replacement guy (laspineinstitute.com) because it means i have to take a day off to drive up there and back. and i'm pretty sure that he'll take one look at my MRI and recommend that i get the procedure. i guess i'm still too scared of back surgery. my pain is bad, but it's not yet bad enough for me to go there....
i feel sure you're aware that most (if not all) of these injections are just band-aids. but i'll take any diminishment of the pain, no matter the source! right now my physical therapy people have me on a detox, gluten-free diet which is supposed to reduce inflammation and pain. i'm on my second day and haven't really seen much improvement so far. but i'll give it another couple of days before i give up.
i've yet to schedule with the disc replacement guy (laspineinstitute.com) because it means i have to take a day off to drive up there and back. and i'm pretty sure that he'll take one look at my MRI and recommend that i get the procedure. i guess i'm still too scared of back surgery. my pain is bad, but it's not yet bad enough for me to go there....
Tuesday, May 6, 2008
status update
from an e-mail to a friend:
i'm not doing well either. called in sick yesterday, and just barely made it in today. i recently got involved with a cute young blonde, but i don't know if i can keep up with her. which really sucks. she's a sweetheart, but i don't want to bring her down.
i'm going to make an appointment with this guy in santa monica who does disc replacements. i don't want surgery, but i'm not sure if i can keep living the way i have been either....
i'm not doing well either. called in sick yesterday, and just barely made it in today. i recently got involved with a cute young blonde, but i don't know if i can keep up with her. which really sucks. she's a sweetheart, but i don't want to bring her down.
i'm going to make an appointment with this guy in santa monica who does disc replacements. i don't want surgery, but i'm not sure if i can keep living the way i have been either....
Friday, May 2, 2008
more PT approved (finally!)
I guess from my perspective, Dr. Dobecki picked a bad time for his wife to have their second baby. Because it has taken far too long to get approval for more physical therapy. But it finally came through (from Dr. Huntley, I think) and I set up a month's worth of appointments starting next week, mainly with Kanoe.
I am eager to get back into the PT because my back has been really day to day. I was doing pretty well at the start of the week, but the last couple days have been rough. I had to take some Flexiril on Wednesday night. I've been taking 300mg of Gabapentin for my evening dose, instead of my usual 100mg. It seems to make me a bit more dopey/sleepy. I didn't necessarily want to increase the dosage, but all the doctors have said I could take way more of the stuff with no harm done. And I've got a prescription bottle full of the 300mg capsules, so why not?
My back hurts right now, probably a 4. It was brutal this morning, maybe a 6 when I woke up. I'll probably reschedule with Rick Delamarter and take a look at the disc replacement. Talked with Dad on the phone, and he made the good point that the recovery time from surgery could be lengthy, and I may need someone to basically take care of me. But what choice do I have? Back pain sucks!
I am eager to get back into the PT because my back has been really day to day. I was doing pretty well at the start of the week, but the last couple days have been rough. I had to take some Flexiril on Wednesday night. I've been taking 300mg of Gabapentin for my evening dose, instead of my usual 100mg. It seems to make me a bit more dopey/sleepy. I didn't necessarily want to increase the dosage, but all the doctors have said I could take way more of the stuff with no harm done. And I've got a prescription bottle full of the 300mg capsules, so why not?
My back hurts right now, probably a 4. It was brutal this morning, maybe a 6 when I woke up. I'll probably reschedule with Rick Delamarter and take a look at the disc replacement. Talked with Dad on the phone, and he made the good point that the recovery time from surgery could be lengthy, and I may need someone to basically take care of me. But what choice do I have? Back pain sucks!
Thursday, May 1, 2008
status update
from an e-mail to a friend:
hey a__,
i hope you are doing well. i am not. my back is killing me! and my doctor is dragging his feet on prescribing more physical therapy. so annoying! it's funny i used to have a strong sex drive, but this back pain doesn't help at all! i hope that some day i'll be able to make up for lost time. ;-)
well, take care and have a good weekend.
-brent
hey a__,
i hope you are doing well. i am not. my back is killing me! and my doctor is dragging his feet on prescribing more physical therapy. so annoying! it's funny i used to have a strong sex drive, but this back pain doesn't help at all! i hope that some day i'll be able to make up for lost time. ;-)
well, take care and have a good weekend.
-brent
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)